blogs created to prevent or detect a crime http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1997/ukpga_19970040_en_1

This blog is brougt to you consistent with subsection 3 of the Protection from Harassment Act - i.e. blogs created to prevent or detect a crime http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1997/ukpga_19970040_en_1



Sunday, 20 June 2010

Seroxat - Coroner disallowed Drug Safety Canada from becoming party to the Carlin Inquest

Terence Young appears as expert witness Sarah Carlin inquest


Friday, June 18, 2010 - Oakville Ontario News



Terence Young MP Oakville and Chair of Drug Safety Canada will be appearing as an expert witness at the Inquest into the Death of Sara Carlin on Friday June 18, 2010 at 9:30 am.



Eighteen year old Sara Carlin of Oakville hanged herself in May 1997 after abruptly discontinuing the prescription drug Paxil.



Young, author of Death by Prescription will testify about how the safety of Paxil was the subject of five Health Canada warning letters sent out to every doctor in Canada regarding suicide and discontinuation symptoms, amongst other risks.



"The death of Sara Carlin is eerily similar to the Death of Vanessa Young in 2000," said Young. "Both cases include a blockbuster drug given for an unapproved use; no patient warning of possible deadly adverse effects from several doctors; and the drug had been the subject of numerous safety warnings for the cause of death.



Sadly nothing significant has changed since Vanessa Young died in 2000. With this inquest we have another chance for change."



The Coroner disallowed Drug Safety Canada from becoming party to the Carlin Inquest, and has severely limited the scope of Young's testimony in advance.





"A favourite trick of the drug companies in these cases is to blame the patient for their own death in court. I hope and pray this Coroner allows the jury to hear the true risks of Paxil related suicide, which include suicide warnings right on the label, and hundreds of settled law suits for Paxil related suicide in the U.S."



Young has introduced a Private Member's Bill onto the Order Paper of Parliament that would create a new independent drug agency for Canada that would regulate safety warnings and other safety matters for Canadians using prescription drugs.

http://www.oakville.com/news/headlines/2010-06-18-terence-young-appears-as-expert-witness-sarah-carlin-inquest

Seroxat - Terence Young MP testifies at Sara Carlin inquest

Oakville MP Terence Young showed no mercy as he testified before the inquest into the death of Sara Carlin Friday blasting Health Canada, GlaxoSmithKline and others for not doing enough to protect Canadians from the dangers of prescription drugs.

http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/836117--young-testifies-at-carlin-inquest

Young, who founded the advocacy group Drug Safety Canada in 2002, was called by the Carlin family's lawyer Gary Will to speak about the adequacy and availability of health information on Paxil to the general public.

The Carlins' daughter Sara had been taking the anti-depressant for more than a year when she hanged herself in her parents' basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.

An inquest has been called by the Ontario Coroner's Office to examine the circumstances surrounding Sara's death and what, if any, role Paxil may have played.

Health Canada has issued a number of advisories stating the drug may increase the risk of suicidal events in children and adolescents under 18.

Young began his testimony by stating he got into drug safety advocacy following the death of his 15-year-old daughter Vanessa, who died of a heart arrhythmia, which he believes was caused by the prescription drug she was taking at the time.

Young said he sees many similarities between what happened to his daughter and what happened to Sara stating that, like Vanessa, the drug Sara was prescribed was 'off label,' meaning it was not recommended for her use.

In Sara's case, this was because she was 17 when she was prescribed Paxil, which was not recommended for people under 18.

Young said that like Vanessa and his family, Sara and her family were given no warnings about some of the greatest side effects associated with the drug she was being given.

Dr. Tom Stanton, the family doctor who prescribed Paxil to Sara, testified he told Sara to come back and see him if she started to feel worse, but did not tell her Paxil may cause suicidal thoughts or behaviour.

Stanton said it is difficult to get patients to begin medications if such information is provided.

Young also said that like the Carlin family, his family only found out about the warnings associated with the drug their daughter was taking after her death when they began to search for information about it online.

When Sara died and Young found out she had been taking Paxil he said he suspected the drug may be involved after discussions with her father.

Young spoke of some of the adverse reactions listed on GlaxoSmithKline's product monograph, such as akathisia.

"Akathisia has been described as a horrible torture where you feel like you want to crawl out of your own skin. It's just a living nightmare. It also says Paxil can cause alcohol abuse and depersonalization. This (depersonalization) is perhaps the worst one where you feel like you're watching yourself, but you can't stop what you're doing," said Young.

"We know Paxil causes nightmares."

At this point Paxil manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline's lawyer Teresa Walsh called on the Coroner to restrict Young to the topics he was called to the inquest to testify about.

Young said that while the possible side effects of Paxil are listed on the product monograph, doctors and patients are not finding them because the warnings are not until page six of the Canadian version.

This is in stark contrast to the Paxil monograph in America, which, Young said, has a warning about the potential for increased suicidality in a separate box on the first page.

"The first thing the doctor sees, the first thing anybody sees, is that anti-depressants increase the risk, compared to a placebo, of suicidality (suicidal thinking and behaviour) in children and adolescents. That's right up there in bold," said Young.

"I think Canadians should get the same safety warnings as Americans."

Young also called for this warning to be written in plain language that is easy to understand.

He pointed out similar recommendations were made following a Coroner's inquest into the death of his daughter Vanessa, but have yet to be carried out.

Young said that when Canadians receive a prescription they should also get some kind of pamphlet outlining what the risks, including worst possible side effects.

Again Young pointed out this is something that is already in place in the United States.

When a new safety issue is found with a medication, Young said, it should be delivered to doctors in a brightly coloured envelope with big letters drawing their attention to the important safety information inside.

He said Health Canada should also purchase ads in newspapers to get the message out when a safety issue is found.

Stanton has testified that he was aware of the Health Canada advisories associated with Paxil when he prescribed it to Sara.

Young also said an independent drug safety agency needs to be set up that would be responsible for things like educating doctors about the safety issues surrounding certain drugs.

This agency he said would receive no funding from drug companies and would be responsible directly to Parliament.

Young currently has a private members' motion before Parliament calling for the creation of such an agency, but says it will be some time before the motion is discussed.

Another recommendation Young brought forward was that drug companies be required to publish the results of all their clinical trials and not just the successful ones.

"It's a huge problem in the pharmaceutical industry called publication bias. In fact, Paxil had clinical trials in New York State, there were seven trials done, one of them showed that Paxil worked better than the placebo, six showed it didn't and those six didn't get published," said Young.

"The attorney general came to an agreement with GlaxoSmithKline that from now on they would publish all their trials for all their drugs on the Internet. That should be done for all trials for every drug and it should certainly be done in Canada."

Young also said patients should be made aware if the drug they are taking has a history of adverse reactions in other countries and said health care professionals should be required to report all suspected adverse drug reactions to Health Canada within 48 hours of the reaction taking place.

During cross-examination Walsh pointed out Young did not know Sara Carlin and as such did not have a great deal of information about the role alcohol or drugs may have played in her suicide.

Young fired back that Walsh was mentioning alcohol over and over again to make sure that was all the jury remembered.

"It's like a bad tune you can't get out of your head," said Young.

"This is leading nowhere."

Walsh also said Young was not a doctor and as such had no medical support for believing Paxil was responsible for Sara's death.

She also said Paxil warnings are present on page three of the product monograph, however, Young noted this warning is not clear.

Walsh also said the Paxil monograph lists the results of the clinical trials conducted stating they did not show the drug to be effective within the pediatric population and as such the drug is not recommended for people under 18.

Walsh next pointed out that all of the adverse reactions Young had listed were only things that had been reported as happening in association with Paxil use, but for which Paxil had not been proven as the cause.

Young did not accept this.

"Who would have a product and put on that product that it might make you want to kill yourself unless they absolutely had to?" asked Young.

Young saved his parting shots for Coroner's counsel Michael Blain whose opening statement, Young said, offered jurors only one side of the story, that being that Sara's suicide had more to do with drugs and alcohol and her brother's death on New Year's Eve 1999, than Paxil.

"It's not my theory sir," said Blain.

"I read the reports, I told the jury what the reports said."

http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/836117--young-testifies-at-carlin-inquest

Saturday, 19 June 2010

Seroxat - MP takes war on drugs to Sara Carlin inquest

MP takes war on drugs to inquest


By SAM PAZZANO, Toronto Sun

Last Updated: June 18, 2010 4:53pm   

 Young started a relentless campaign to prevent tragedies linked to prescription drugs when his teenaged daughter died after taking a since-banned drug Prepulsid for bloating in 2000.


He used a coroner’s inquest Friday to champion a host of changes aimed at protecting Canadians by making them aware of the dangerous side effects of prescription drugs.

The 57-year-old MP testified at the inquest examining the May 6, 2007 suicide of athlete-scholar Sara Carlin after the 18-year-old took an anti-depressant drug called Paxil.

Her parents are blaming the drug for her death.

Sara hanged herself in the basement of her parents’ Oakville home after taking Paxil for 14 months.

Young emphasized that patients must be educated about the dangerous side effects of drugs and the possibility of using alternate non-drug treatments.

“Doctors indicate to patients there’s a pill for everything and there are alternate treatments (that are not presented),” said Young, who founded the advocacy group Drug Safety Canada and last year wrote a scathing book Death By Prescription, which indicts the lucrative North American drug industry of placing profit before patient safety.

Young’s happy 15-year-old daughter Vanessa died in front of him on March 19, 2000. He blamed the medication Prepulsid prescribed by the family’s doctor. He sued its manufacturer and settled in February 2006.

Prepulsid, which was prescribed to aid digestion, was tied to irregular heartbeat and was linked to heart attacks and sudden death, mostly in people also using some other medications or suffering from some underlying conditions.

Janssen Pharmaceutica voluntarily stopped marketing Prepulsid in the U.S. in July 2000. Health Canada pulled it from Canadian shelves one month later, saying its decision was “founded on the association of the drug with serious cardiac arrhythmias ... and sudden cardiac deaths.”

Doctors must explain the drug’s risks, benefits and adverse side effects so patients can make informed choices, Young said. Despite existing warnings of teen use of Paxil, Young said the drug’s sales escalated from 2005 through 2008.

Health Canada issued warnings in 2003 and 2004 that prescribing antidepressants to teens could lead to behavioural or emotional changes that might put them at increased risk of suicidal behaviour.

A year before her death, Sara had complained of anxiety and depression to her family doctor and had been prescribed Paxil, one of the antidepressants known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs).

Her downward spiral included using cocaine and binge drinking, quitting her University of Western Ontario second-year course and her job.

Her worried parents, Rhonda and Neil, learned she was now on four prescribed medications: Paxil, a second antidepressant, Ativan and a sleeping pill before her death.

“We’re hoping through this inquest Sara will save some lives down the road and that’s what gives us a tremendous sense of meaning,” her father, Neil, said.

Lawyer Teresa Walsh, representing Paxil’s makers, queried Young on Sara Carlin’s alcohol consumption two years before taking Paxil.

Young balked at the questions, refusing to answer them and noting by Grade 10 alcohol use is widespread.

“It’s irrelevant. You’re planting the earworm (idea) that it’s the alcohol, everything but the Paxil,” replied Young, who was warned by the coroner to simply answer Walsh’s questions.

The inquest will conclude Monday with closing arguments.
sam.pazzano@sunmedia.ca

http://www.torontosun.com/news/torontoandgta/2010/06/18/14442356.html

Friday, 18 June 2010

Paroxetine-induced increase in activity of locus coeruleus neurons in adolescent rats: implication of a countertherapeutic effect of an antidepressant.

Paroxetine-induced increase in activity of locus coeruleus neurons in adolescent rats: implication of a countertherapeutic effect of an antidepressant.


West CH, Ritchie JC, Weiss JM.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20357759

Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA 30306, USA. cwest@emory.edu



Comment in:



Neuropsychopharmacology. 2010 Jul;35(8):1619-20.



Abstract

The concern that antidepressant (AD) drugs, especially selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors and paroxetine (PAR) in particular, can increase suicidality during the early treatment of juvenile patients (children and adolescents) has created a dilemma for clinicians treating depressives. Although preclinical research cannot resolve controversy in this area, our present findings may provide insight into how AD drugs might, under certain conditions, exacerbate rather than ameliorate the depressive state. Both clinical and preclinical evidences indicate that the principal noradrenergic cell group in the brain, the locus coeruleus (LC), is overactive in depressives and that, conversely, effective AD treatments decrease the activity of LC neurons. We report here that short-term (2 and 4 days) administration of PAR produces an increase in the activity of LC neurons (spontaneous firing rate and sensory-evoked responses) in young rats, contrary to the 'therapeutic' decrease in activity typically observed in adult rats. Blood levels of PAR were lower in young rats than in adult rats, although similar low blood levels produced by a lower dose of PAR in adult rats failed to produce an increase in LC activity. In addition, activity of young rats in the swim test was determined to assess depressive-like responses. The same dose/durations of PAR, which produced the largest increases in LC activity in young rats, produced decreases in swim-test activity, indicating that brief administration of PAR in young rats can promote, rather than reduce, the depressive state. These results offer a model that may help screen potential adjunctive treatments to avoid early adverse effects of ADs.



PMID: 20357759 [PubMed - in process]





Publication Types, Grant SupportPublication Types: Research Support, N.I.H., ExtramuralGrant Support:MH079794/MH/NIMH NIH HHS/United States

LinkOut - more resources

Seroxat - Expert and family friend disagree on impact of Paxil @ Carlin inquest

Expert and family friend disagree on impact of Paxil




Expert and family friend disagree on impact of Paxil. Supplied photo Related Stories •Sara Carlin inquest begins

•Doctors describe Sara Carlin as troubled

•Erratic behaviour alarmed friends

•'I'm so low, I'm hurting'

•Should parents have been told daughter was prescribed anti-depressant?

It's possible, but not probable.

This was the dominating message that emerged Thursday, the ninth day of an inquest into the death of 18-year-old Sara Carlin, as lawyers hammered away at an expert witness in the field of suicide over the role Paxil played in her death.

Sara, an Oakville resident and graduate St. Ignatius of Loyola Catholic Secondary School, hanged herself in her parents' basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.

Doctors had been prescribing her the anti-depressant Paxil for more than a year before her death despite Health Canada advisories stating the drug could increase the risk of suicidal events in children and adolescents under 18.

The inquest into Sara's death has been called by the Ontario Coroner's Office to examine the circumstances surrounding her death and, if possible, make recommendations to prevent similar deaths in the future.

During his testimony, Dr. Paul Links, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Toronto, deputy chief of psychiatry at St. Michael's Hospital, and past president of the Canadian Association for Suicide Prevention, said he did not see Paxil as the most viable explanation for Sara's death.

While Links agreed Paxil could produce suicidal thoughts and behaviour, he said this was unlikely in Sara's case. He said Sara had been taking Paxil for more than a year and the risky period for suicide is in the first months.

To his knowledge, Links said there was no dramatic period of restlessness, agitation or dramatic shifts in her mood that would show the drug was having a negative effect on her.

The inquest did here a contrary opinion to this analysis, on Thursday, from long time Carlin family friend Gillian Kerr, who joined a number of past witnesses in stating Sara's behaviour did radically change after she started taking Paxil in February of 2006.

Kerr said she had known the Carlin family for 26 years even serving as their live-in nanny at one point.

She developed a close relationship with Sara, similar to that of an aunt. Kerr said she supported Sara at a large number of the athletic events, as well as during music recitals and other important events in her life.

"Sara was amazing," said Kerr, choking back tears. "She had a great sense of humour, she was very loving. The whole entire family was very affectionate and that was Sara. She was just wonderful, she had a good heart, she was a very hard worker, not only at school, but around the house."

Kerr said, however, a different Sara emerged in the weeks following her introduction to Paxil.

The family had been getting ready for a family member's birthday party and Kerr had come to the Carlin family home from London around 2 p.m.

She went to check on Sara and found her in bed unwilling to move.

"I said, 'We need to get to your Aunt Christine's house in an hour. You better get up and shower.' and she snapped at me, which was a shock to me," said Kerr.

"She was very moody, didn't want to go to the family event. I asked what was going on with her, but she didn't answer me, just grumbled."

Sara did end up going to the party and here, too, Kerr noticed behaviour that she said was completely out of character for Sara.

Previously, Kerr said, Sara had always played with her aunt's young children and had been the centre of attention at these parties, but this time Sara just sat in a corner.

When the party ended at around 6:30 p.m., Kerr said, Sara returned home and went back to bed.

Kerr recalled another incident in July 2006 when she entered Sara's room and found a huge hole in the wall.

When she asked her about it, Sara said she had punched the hole in the wall one day when she was angry.

When Kerr asked Sara what had made her so angry, she said Sara was not able to provide a reason.

On another occasion, Kerr remembered Sara becoming frustrated while trying to load the dishwasher. Sara ended up throwing a bowl on the counter and slamming the dishwasher door shut when the bowl wouldn't fit.

Sara then left the room amid a flurry of profanities.

All of this was new behaviour for Sara, Kerr said.

Other witnesses have testified alcohol and drug abuse also became a problem for Sara during this period. Her autopsy showed she had consumed a large amount of alcohol (twice the legal limit had she been driving) the night before her death.

Chemicals consistent with cocaine use taking place within 48 hours of her death were also found.

With this information, Links has argued a combination of depression, anxiety and substance abuse were the more likely the cause of Sara's suicide, particularly because alcohol is a disinhibitor and consuming large amounts can make people do things they normally would not do.

Cocaine is also dangerous for someone with depression or anxiety, Links said, as coming down from a cocaine high can cause dysphoria, the sudden onset of additional depression.

The Carlins’ lawyer Gary Will, however, argued the explanation is not that simple.

He drew Links attention to Paxil manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline's product monograph for Paxil. This monograph, Will said, lists a number of side-effects associated with taking Paxil, which include depression, increased alcohol consumption, possible drug dependence, trouble articulating words, paranoid reactions, thinking abnormally, rapidly changing mood and Akathisia, a horrific restlessness and inner torment.

On cross-examination GlaxoSmithKline lawyer Teresa Walsh said these side effects have only been reported in association with taking Paxil. She said there is no evidence Paxil causes them.

Links said he saw no evidence Sara was suffering from any of these side effects, but acknowledged that Akathisia, which can lead to suicide, can be internalized.

Will also noted a sudden stoppage in drug treatment, as Sara experienced for two to three days near the end of her life, could result in dysphoria and suicidality. Links said this was possible.

Links said it was also possible that restarting the medication after a period of absence could lead to disinhibition and possible suicidal thoughts or behaviour.

He added, however, that it was more common for the withdrawal symptoms a person is experiencing to simply be alleviated when a person begins taking Paxil again.

In the end, Links said it was plausible Sara's suicide was the result of the Paxil, but said this he was not in favour of that explanation.

When asked about Paxil treatment, Links said it is important to involve the family in the treatment plan for drugs like Paxil, but

added he would have to respect the request of a youth 16 years of age or older to keep their medical information confidential.

Kerr testified she tried to accompany Sara during a session with Dr. Lynne Benjamin, so she could discuss the effect she felt the Paxil was having on Sara, but was stopped by Benjamin.

It was later pointed out that Sara did not tell Benjamin, in Kerr's presence, that it was okay for Kerr to come inside the doctor's office for the session.

Links said psychotherapy is an important part of treatment. However, he said the patient has to attend therapy voluntarily. Therapy can't be compelled unless it is determined the patient is an immediate threat to themselves or others.

Sara was referred to a psychotherapist and Halton ADAPT (Alcohol Drug and Gambling Assessment Prevention and Treatment Services). However, in both cases she stopped going after only a single session.

Links said there was nothing he had read that indicated Sara was not capable of making her own choices. He said as an adult she could choose not to return.

While Links may have had some doubts about Paxil's role in Sara's death, he had none about suicide being a problem among adolescents in Canada.

Links said there are around 3,600 suicides in Canada every year with Canada currently having a suicide rate of 12 to 13 per 100,000 people with the numbers being higher for youth.

In a 2001 survey it was found that 19 per cent of high school students had thought about suicide, 15 per cent had actually formulated a suicide plan at some point while 9 per cent reported a suicide attempt.

To combat this Links said Canada needs to put together a national suicide prevention strategy to break down the stigma around mental illness, so more people get help when they need it.

The strategy would also work to improve access to mental health services.

http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/835844--expert-and-family-friend-disagree-on-impact-of-paxil

Thursday, 17 June 2010

Seroxat - Crisis expert says Paxil may have been factor in suicide

Crisis expert says Paxil may have been factor in suicide. Sara Carlin Supplied photo Related Stories •Sara Carlin inquest begins


A second expert witness called by the Coroner's Counsel, Wednesday, has said Paxil use may have been a contributing factor in the death of Sara Carlin.


The 18-year-old Oakville woman and graduate of St. Ignatius of Loyola had been taking the anti-depressant about a year when she hanged herself in the basement of her family home on Sunday, May 6, 2007.

A coroner's inquest into her death is being held to examine the circumstances surrounding that death and determine if Paxil played a role in it. Health Canada has issued advisories warning Paxil can increase the risk of suicidal events in people under 18, had.

Dr. Nathan Scharf was qualified by the Coroner's Counsel Michael Blain as an expert in the area of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) use in children and adolescents because of his work as director of crisis services at the Youthdale Treatment Centre in Toronto.

The centre provides emergency crisis intervention for children and adolescents found to be at risk.

Blain said Scharf works with young people at the centre as a psychiatrist.

When asked by Blain to comment on Sara's case, Scharf initially said Paxil was probably not a major contributor to her death because she had been taking the Paxil since February of 2006 and most suicidal thoughts and adverse effects take place in the first few weeks if they are going to take place at all.

As Sara had been quite far along in her Paxil treatment, Scharf said it was more likely her suicide was a result of other things going on in her life.

This opinion was also shared by the Coroner's Counsel's previous expert witness, Dr. David Juurlink.

On cross-examination, however, Carlin's lawyer Gary Will pointed out that Scharf had very little information on Sara's case. He had received only a page and a half summary from the Coroner's Office.

This summary included no medical records from Sara's doctors or statements from her parents about how they feel she changed when she began taking Paxil. Her parents have testified she changed from an academically and athletically focused young woman to an apathetic person who abused drugs and alcohol.

Will listed a number of incidents in which Sara's Paxil dose increase was followed shortly by some adverse behaviour on her part.

This included the Palm Springs incident, which occurred a few weeks after Sara began taking Paxil.

The Carlins have testified that Sara spent most of the time in bed with the blinds pulled down during a family trip to Palm Springs. They considered is very out of character for her.

When the Paxil dosage was moved from 10 mgs to 20 mgs, Will said Sara suddenly quite her part-time job at an optometrist's office.

Steve Schenke, who is representing three doctors associated with treating Sara, contested this statement. He said employment records indicate Sara left this job in June.

Will said soon after the Paxil level was moved from 20 mgs to 30 mgs in September, Sara wrote a letter to herself that some have characterized as being close to a suicide note.

Another dose increase from 30 mgs to 40 mgs in October was followed a week later by Sara being taken to a London emergency room after mixing sleeping pills, cocaine and alcohol.

Scharf said he was not aware of any of these incidents or their proximity to the Paxil dose increases.

When asked if he believed Paxil could cause suicide, Scharf said he did not believe there was a 'suicide button' within a person that Paxil could switch on, but said Paxil can cause agitation, sleep disturbances and increased anxiety, which in turn can lead to suicidal ideation.

Will next talked about Sara's Paxil prescription going missing for two to three days in early May during the last days of her life.

He asked Scharf about SSRI Discontinuation Syndrome and if side effects of a Paxil withdrawal could include suicidal ideation.

"I haven't experienced that in my practice. I have seen literature that would suggest that as a possibility," said Scharf.

"I accept that."

Will said that when Sara's Paxil prescription was refilled she may have taken as much as 120 mgs in a 36-hour period to make up the doses she missed.

Will asked Scharf if such a scenario could have played a role in her suicide.

"Certainly, it may have played a role. I cannot say it did not play a role," said Scharf. "It was perhaps one factor among others."

When cross-examined by Schenke, Scharf agreed it was more likely the large amount of alcohol Sara ingested the night before her death was a greater contributing factor to her suicide than Paxil, but stopped short of saying it was completely responsible for her death.

In addition to speaking about Sara's case, Scharf also talked about the process he goes through before putting someone on an SSRI at his practice.

Scharf said a physical evaluation takes place to ensure there is no underlying medical condition that could be contributing to or masquerading as a psychiatric condition.

Laboratory investigations are also conducted so Scharf can make sure the person is not anemic, that they have a properly functioning liver and kidneys, that they are not diabetic or pregnant.

Scharf said he typically works with a parent or guardian to work out when the medication would be introduced, who is going to monitor the child, how the medication will be dispensed, how issues of missed medication will be dealt with and how long the course of treatment will be.

Although Sara was 17 years and seven months old at the time she was prescribed Paxil and entitled to confidentiality, Scharf said he would have urged her to involve her family for the purpose of monitoring the drug.

He said it was appropriate for family practitioners to inform patients and their families about the side effects of the drug, especially if the side effects can lead to suicidal thoughts or even suicide.

Earlier this week, the inquiry heard testimony from Dr. Tom Stanton, Sara's family doctor, who said the appointment Sara was put on Paxil lasted for about 30 minutes.

He said he did not tell Sara about the risk of suicidal events associated with Paxil because patients are less likely to actually take the drug when told this.

During her cross-examination, Teresa Walsh, lawyer for Paxil manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline, pointed out that a family doctor, who has looked after a patient for a number of years, would already know much of the information sought in Scharf’s extensive examinations.

Stanton also testified the Carlin family was not provided information about Sara starting Paxil because Sara wanted her medical information kept confidential and that he had told Sara that if the medication made her feel worse she should come back.

It was also pointed out that Scharf's work at a crisis centre is very different than the work that goes on at a family doctor's office with Scharf seeing far fewer patients than a family doctor.

GlaxoSmithKline, the manufacturer of Paxil, has previously stated that patients should not stop taking Paxil without first consulting their doctor.

Any concerns with the use of Paxil, should be discussed with the patient’s health-care professional
/www.insidehalton.com/news/article/835177--crisis-expert-says-paxil-may-have-been-factor-in-suicide

Wednesday, 16 June 2010

Seroxat - Expert witness rules out Paxil in Sara Carlin's suicide

An expert witness called by the Coroner's Counsel acknowledged, Tuesday, that anti-depressants can cause suicidal thoughts and suicide, but said he does not believe this happened in the case of Sara Carlin, 18.


Sara, an Oakville resident and graduate of St. Ignatius of Loyola Catholic Secondary School, hanged herself in her parents' basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.

A coroner's inquest into her death is now being held because in the months leading up to her death she had been taking Paxil, an anti-depressant, which Health Canada has warned can increase the risk of suicidal events in the children and adolescents under 18 who take them.

read on - http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/834211--expert-witness-rules-out-paxil-in-sara-carlin-s-suicide

Tuesday, 15 June 2010

Seroxat - Doctors describe Sara Carlin as troubled

.Doctors describe Sara Carlin as troubled




Doctors describe Sara Carlin as troubled. Sara Carlin Two doctors who treated Sara Carlin during the last year of her life say the 18-year-old's problems began well before one of them introduced her to Paxil in February of 2006.

Sara, an Oakville resident and graduate of St. Ignatius of Loyola Catholic Secondary School, hanged herself in her parents' basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.

Since that time much has been made of the fact that Sara had been taking Paxil, an anti-depressant Health Canada has issued numerous advisories for because of the possible increased risk of suicidal events among the children and adolescents under 18 who take it.

On Monday, a coroner's inquest into Sara's death heard from Sara's family physician, Dr. Tom Stanton and Psychotherapist Dr. Mary Alexander.

The jury has heard from Sara's family that Sara was experiencing some anxiety during her last year of high school, as she was preparing to leave home for university, and went to Stanton to see what could be done to alleviate it.

Stanton testified about this 30-minute visit, which took place on Feb. 20, 2006, stating far more was going on with Sara than just a little anxiety.

"Her presenting problem, what she stated to me first, was that she was having a lot of anxiety. She said she'd seen a naturopath in the past for the same thing, but the naturopath medications she'd been given didn't work," said Stanton.

"Then she went on to describe her symptoms, her hands were clammy, she was short of breath, she was having episodes of sweatiness, she was pale, she couldn't control these episodes, she was extremely emotional during the episodes, she was having two or three of them everyday and they were lasting for between five and ten minutes each time."

According to Shannon, Sara said she was having trouble sleeping, that she was having lots of nightmares, that she had no energy and was feeling very negative and depressed.

When questioned about the stress in her life, Stanton said Sara told him she had a heavy workload at school, she was having trouble with her boyfriend and there was a lot of tension at home
 
read on - http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/833604--doctors-describe-sara-carlin-as-troubled

Monday, 14 June 2010

Seroxat - Should parents have been told daughter was prescribed anti-depressant?

Should parents have been told daughter was prescribed anti-depressant?.

If a patient’s life is at risk should their doctor warn that patient’s family, even without the patient’s consent?

Rhonda Carlin says if her family doctor and others had done this, her daughter might still be alive.

Rhonda testified to this effect, on Friday, during the fifth day of a coroner’s inquest into the death of Sara Carlin.
Sara, 18, an Oakville resident and graduate of St. Ignatius of Loyola Catholic Secondary School, hanged herself in her parents’ basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.
At the time, she had been taking Paxil, an anti-depressant, which Health Canada has issued advisories for due to the possible increased risk of suicidal events for children and adolescents who take it.

From the outset of the inquest, Gary Will, the Carlins' lawyer has been attempting to link Paxil to Sara's downward spiral and death, while the Coroner's Counsel, lawyers representing Paxil manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline and lawyers representing three doctors associated with treating Sara, have brought forward other theories about her suicide.

These include theories that she was driven to suicide through drug and alcohol consumption or because of the sadness she felt over the death of her brother Brendan, who died of a drug overdose on New Year's Eve 1999.

read on - http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/833099--should-parents-have-been-told-daughter-was-prescribed-anti-depressant

Seroxat - How Jofre failed all antidepressant patients whilst serving Mark Harvey of Hugh James



Seroxat secrets - Scientology / CCHR bought & paid for ?


http://seroxatsecrets.wordpress.com/2010/06/14/the-mhra-and-glaxos-solicitiors-just-how-close-are-they/

Sunday, 13 June 2010

Paxil Protest website removed as part of a confidentiality agreement or 'gagging order'

According to the Paxil Protest website,[36] hundreds more lawsuits have been filed against GSK. The original Paxil Protest website was removed from the internet in 2006. It is understood that the action to take down the site was undertaken as part of a confidentiality agreement or 'gagging order' which the owner of the site entered
 
 

Rob Robinson - paid by GSK to go away !






http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:XYY3cwGvH_sJ:en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GlaxoSmithKline+paxil+protest+wikipedia&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk

deluded Rob Robinson claimed "As many as 1,000 or more protesters might attend the Paxil Protest."

The Paxil Protest web site also includes important information for Paxil users who might wish to quit the drug. "What I did not want to have happen is to have Paxil users come to the site, panic, and then abruptly quit the drug. The consequences could be disastrous. That's why an entire web page addresses the issue of how to get off Paxil safely, or as safely as possible."




"I am confident the public as well as the media will discover information that is newsworthy and highly informative on virtually every page of the Paxil Protest web site" Robinson said. "Plenty of story angles to be had," he added.



Robinson, a Paxil survivor himself, said it took several years of intermittent but intensive research to assemble the information presented at the Paxil Protest web site. "My goal was to make it as easy as possible for the public to get to the truth about Paxil - the sinister truth which GlaxosmithKline hides from the world." He describes the Paxil Protest web site as 'the definitive Paxil Information Clearinghouse.'



As many as 1,000 or more protesters might attend the Paxil Protest. "We simply have no way of forecasting how many people might show up; after all, the call to action is going out the world over," Robinson said.



Victims and survivors of other SSRI drugs such as Prozac, Effexor and Zoloft are also expected to attend in a show of community support.



Contact: Rob Robinson

The Paxil Protest

http://www.paxilprotest.com/

423-265-5604

http://www.ahrp.org/infomail/05/09/18a.php

Paxil protest - reality check !













Image source - http://img513.imageshack.us/i/img00342gy.jpg/


 
 
more here - http://www.thepaxilprotest.com/images/Paxil_Protest_web_site.pdf

Friday, 11 June 2010

Seroxat - Mother describes daughter's downward spiral

Mother describes daughter's downward spiral


She's had to listen to the graphic description of her daughter's autopsy and testimony from multiple witnesses about the sad decline of a girl who showed so much promise.

On Thursday, the forth day of a coroner's inquest into the death of Sara Carlin, Sara's mother Rhonda took the witness stand to talk about her daughter and the events surrounding her death.

Sara, 18, an Oakville resident and graduate of St. Ignatius of Loyola Catholic Secondary School, hanged herself in her parents’ basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.

At the time, she had been taking Paxil, an anti-depressant, which Health Canada has issued advisories for due to the possible increased risk of suicidal events for children and adolescents who take it.

read on - http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/832591--mother-describes-daughter-s-downward-spiral

Paxil / Seroxat - Sara Carlin had drug debts & mixed meds with with alcohol and cocaine.

The girl with every reason to live


By MICHELE MANDEL, Toronto Sun

http://www.torontosun.com/news/columnists/michele_mandel/2010/06/10/14340951.html

Last Updated: June 10, 2010 8:18pm

Email StoryPrintSize A A AReport TypoShare with:

FacebookDiggDel.icio.usGoogleStumble UponNewsvineRedditTechnoratiFeed MeYahooSimpySquidooSpurlBlogmarksNetvouzScuttleSitejot+ What are these? .

At graduation, Sara Carlin was a straight-A student who dreamed of becoming a doctor. (Photo courtesy the Carlin family) Sara Carlin had everything to live for: She was smart, athletic, beautiful and pursuing her dream of becoming a doctor.



But on May 6, 2007, that bright future ended abruptly with a piece of electrical wire.



The promising 18-year-old had hung herself in her family’s Oakville basement and her grieving parents blame her suicide on the Paxil antidepressant she’d been prescribed more than a year before.



In emotional testimony that left many fighting back tears, Sara’s mother Rhonda told a coroner’s inquest that her daughter earned 90’s in school, played baseball and women’s hockey, held a part-time job at an optometrist’s office and tutored other kids in math.



“She was a pretty exceptional girl, she was absolutely loving and she was beautiful,” her mom proudly recalled Wednesday before the presiding coroner, Dr. Bert Lauwers. “She really was an exceptional daughter.”



But in the early part of 2006, Sara began to change. During the family’s March break vacation to Palm Springs, she wouldn’t get out of bed most days and got drunk at dinner. “It was so unlike her,” her mom said.



It was only later that she learned Sara had complained of anxiety and depression to her family doctor and had recently been prescribed Paxil, one of the antidepressants known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs).



“I said, ‘Why on earth, Sara would you be on antidepressants?’ I was astounded,” she recalled for the five-member jury. “Why, why would he be giving these to her? This was a wonderful, happy girl.”



While Sara lost her much older brother to a drug overdose in 2000, her mother believed her daughter had coped well with his death and never wanted the counselling she’d been offered.



So this need for antidepressants, she said, came out of the blue.



“She was very troubled, much more troubled than any of us knew,” her mother acknowledged.



While her parents repeatedly voiced their reservations about Paxil, Sara brushed them off, saying her doctor told her it would make her feel better. “I didn’t even know the horrific side effects of Paxil at that time,” her mom said. “I certainly didn’t know what I know now.”



Health Canada issued warnings in 2003 and 2004 that prescribing antidepressants to teens could lead to behavioural or emotional changes that might put them at increased risk of suicidal behaviour.



Over the next few months, Sara’s behaviour changed even more. She suddenly quit her job and stopped playing hockey. Her mom said she was unaware Sara was drinking and doing cocaine; she just knew she wasn’t herself.



“She was really lethargic and tired and pale. She’d lost weight. We were concerned. “



Just as she was starting her first year in health sciences at the University of Western Ontario, Sara was diagnosed with mononeucleosis. Her parents were almost relieved, hoping it explained the change in their daughter.



But her downward spiral continued at university to the point where she had drug debts, was missing classes and was eventually taken by ambulance to a London emergency room after mixing her prescription medications with alcohol and cocaine.



She withdrew from school and came home to Oakville.



It was the first time her mom learned Sara was doing coke and was now on four prescribed medications: Paxil, a second antidepressant, Ativan and a sleeping pill.

http://www.torontosun.com/news/columnists/michele_mandel/2010/06/10/14340951.html






The night before her suicide, Sara held a pre-drink for friends in her basement and then headed to a local pub where she continued drinking. A friend eventually drove her home, but not before stopping at a home where he thinks she picked up drugs.



When her mom found her room empty the next morning, she just assumed Sara had gone out early for breakfast. As the day wore on, she and her husband Neil became increasingly worried when no one could locate her.



“Then I heard Neil just screaming, screaming and you could hear it all the way in the backyard,” she recalled, the tears rolling down her face. “Neil was screaming, ‘She hung herself.’”



Read Mandel Wednesday through Saturday. michele.mandel@sunmedia.ca or 416-947-2231

Thursday, 10 June 2010

Seroxat - How the BBC misled UK viewers in attempt to bolster UK Class Action

Podcast transcript -

Jofre says although problems with whole class of antidepressants we (bbc) decided to concentrate on Seroxat







http://coventryuniversity.podbean.com/2007/11/01/one-woman-a-multinational-and-a-victory-shelley-jofre-panorama/


2.30 in Jofre says - " read a little bit in news paper about patients complaints" year 2000 about " Seroxat difficult to withdraw from" .. Jofre found it intriguing Jofre had only just started working on Panorama at that stage3.30 in " Jofre calls SSRI's "SELECTIVE Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors"4.14 Jofre knew little of how the pharmcutical industry worked4 .30 in Ed says - lets look at antidepressant story4 45 Jofre says although problems with whole class of antidepressants we (bbc) decided to concentrate on SeroxatWhy we narrowed down on Seroxat1 because it was made by GSK2 all the drugs in class cause suicidal thinking on dose change3 Seroxat had a unique problem of withdrawal BECAUSE IT WAS LONGER ACTING ... we decided to focus research into this drug 6.00 in - 40 min Panorama film took Shelley Jofre 8 months to make6.10 in - It's not something you do lightly WE WERE TAKING ON the worlds second largest drug company7.30 We were talking to the lawyer the whole way through production9.30 in - Jofre says "we took a punt" on Dr David Healy

see also -

http://www.paxilprogress.org/forums/showthread.php?t=43019&highlight=podcast

Seroxat Sara Carlin inquest - boyfriend believed she was on cocaine two days before death

.'I'm so low, I'm hurting'





Sara Carlin's text to boyfriend two days before her suicide







'I'm so low, I'm hurting'. Sara Carlin Oakville Beaver file photo Related Stories •Sara Carlin inquest begins



More clues about Sara Carlin's state of mind during her final days of life surfaced, Wednesday, during the third day of a coroner's inquest into the death of the 18-year-old Oakville woman.







Sara, a graduate of St. Ignatius of Loyola Catholic Secondary School, hanged herself in her parent's basement on Sunday, May 6, 2007.







At the time Sara had been taking Paxil, a powerful anti-depressant, which Health Canada has issued advisories for due to the possible increased risk of suicidal events in children and adolescents who take it.







Throughout the inquest, Gary Will, lawyer for the Carlin family, has attempted to link Sara's introduction to the drug in February 2006 to her downward spiral of out of control behavior, which ended with her death.







Lawyers for Paxil manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline, three doctors who put Sara on Paxil, and the coroner's council have suggested other reasons behind her suicide.







The inquest has been called by the Ontario Coroner's Office to examine the events surrounding Sara's death to determine if it was preventable and what recommendations, if any, can be made to stop similar deaths from happening in the future.







Throughout Wednesday, the Coroner's Counsel Michael Blain called a number of witnesses to the stand.







This included Adam Currie, who dated Sara for the final two weeks of her life.







The jury heard Currie and Sara had been acquaintances for years through mutual friends, but only started dating in late April 2007.







Currie said the relationship involved considerable binge drinking at friends’ homes and bars, paid for largely by Currie.







Friends of Sara's have previously testified she was into cocaine during this period, but Currie said she never witnessed her using it.







Currie also mentioned Sara had told him she was suffering from vicious nightmares and drank excessively so she could black out and thereby silence them.







When it came to the Paxil she was taking, Currie said all he knew was that it was for anxiety and that Sara had been talking about going off it gradually.







"This was something on her mind, but it was never executed to my knowledge," he said.







On May 4, two days before Sara's death, Currie said the two had gone to an Oakville bar, but Currie became upset when Sara began spending time with a man with whom she'd had a previous relationship.







As the bar was closing, Currie said Sara opted to stay with this man, at which point Currie grew angry and left.







The next morning at around 8 a.m. the two exchanged a series of heated phone calls and text messages.







Currie said Sara was incoherent and whispering into the phone.







He said he believed she was on cocaine and became angry, as she had stayed at the other man's house overnight.



read on - http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/831698--i-m-so-low-i-m-hurting

Scientology's Evelyn Pringle documents passed by Fiddaman to Mark Harvey of Hugh James

extract -


It could be argued that that Glaxo's expert statistician isn't that expert after all. His study has come under fire from many, as have his statistics.




Gibbons CV can be read here.  



Special thanks to investigative journalist, Evelyn Pringle, for passing on documents regarding Dr. Robert Gibbons, many of which, have been forwarded to the solicitors representing the plaintiffs in the UK Seroxat Group Action.



Coming soon: Part IV - Another Glaxo expert witnessed revealed...along with his ties to Glaxo and it's huge donations.

http://fiddaman.blogspot.com/2010/06/glaxosmithklinemhra-when-ignorance_05.html




Fid

Sarah Carlin "deeply upset about her brother's drug overdose"

On cross-examination, GlaxoSmithKline (Paxil manufacturer) lawyer Teresa Walsh asked Desimo if Sara had said anything about Paxil making her fell better.

"She just said she needed her pills," he responded.

Walsh asked how much Desimo had really known about what was going on with Sara since she had only mentioned her brother Brendan to him on one or two occasions.

A previous witness testified Sara was still deeply upset about her brother's drug overdose, which happened during the 1999 New Year's Eve, stating in 2006 that she wanted to be with him again.

Lawyer Nancy McAuley, representing three doctors who put Sara on Paxil, also cross-examined Desimo. Under cross-examination, Desimo said Sara had occasionally smoked marijuana early in their relationship.

McAuley asked if it was fair to say Sara was experimenting with different drugs.

Sara's friends, Stephanie Wood and Lindsay Liptok, also testified about the changes they observed in Sara's behaviour in 2006.

Wood had known Carlin since Grade 7 and described her as a smart person and a great hockey player.

The two became close friends in Grade 10 and spent a great deal of time together.

Wood said they would go to parties and Sara would drink alcohol, but added this was not unusual. Wood said most of her other friends started drinking around Grade 10.

Wood acknowledged Sara would use marijuana on occasion, but nothing stronger.

Wood said this changed in the summer of 2006. During a cottage party Sara appeared to be far more intoxicated than the others present and appeared, said Wood, to be on something besides alcohol, possibly cocaine.

During the party, Wood said, Sara walked out by the lake and made some unsettling statements.

"She was saying nothing matters and if she fell in the water it wouldn't matter and no one should try to help her," said Wood. "She eventually listened to me and came back inside the cottage."

Wood said she witnessed Sara taking her medication while intoxicated, something the literature on Paxil warns against.

http://www.insidehalton.com/news/article/830863--erratic-behaviour-alarmed-friends